Massachusetts Workers Comp Case – DiCarlo Is A Landmark Victory for Workers

No Workers Comp Lien for Pain and Suffering in Third-Party Settlements

In a landmark case (DiCarlo vs. Suffolk Construction), the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court issued a decision today that states once and for all that there is no workers’ compensation lien for pain and suffering in third-party settlements. This is a HUGE victory for injured workers and ensures that the workers’ compensation insurer cannot claim an entire third-party settlement.  If you were injured on the job, contact John J. Sheehan- an experienced Boston Workers Compensation Attorney- TODAY!

Massachusetts Workers Compensation Law

Massachusetts Supreme Court logo- MA Courts ruled in favor of Injured WorkersUnder M.G.L. Ch. 152 et seq., an employee injured on the job is entitled to workers’ compensation benefits which include lost wage benefits and medical benefits. There is no direct compensation under the Massachusetts workers comp statute for pain and suffering. Sometimes an injured worker is hurt on the job due to some other person or company’s fault or negligence. In those cases where a worker is hurt on the job due to an accident or unsafe or dangerous condition caused by some person or company not part of the worker’s employer, the injured worker may bring a third party claim seeking damages – including pain and suffering — from the persons or companies who caused the work injury. Since pain and suffering is not covered under the Massachusetts workers comp law, the Court decided that there is not workers’ compensation lien on the amount of a third party settlement that covers pain and suffering.

Impact of the DiCarlo Decision

In certain cases, the amount of the third party settlement may be less than the total amount of the workers’ compensation lien depending on the amount of insurance a third party defendant may have or depending on the strength of the third party case. If there is a possibility that he or she might lose at trial, an injured worker may accept a compromise settlement that will guarantee a sum certain. Before the DiCarlo Decision, a workers’ compensation insurer could compromise and reduce its lien allowing the injured worker to receive a certain amount of the third party settlement. There was nothing the law could do to force a workers’ comp insurer to compromise and reduce its lien. Sometimes the insurer might try to grab all or most of the settlement especially if the lien was far greater than the amount of the third party settlement. Now, the injured worker is guaranteed a certain amount of the third party settlement for pain and suffering. The rest of the settlement would cover the attorney’s fees, legal expenses and the workers comp lien.

Calculating Settlements in Massachusetts Workers Compensation Cases

Massachuetts Workers Compensation case- Dicarlo is a win for workersThe Court did not give an exact formula outlining how pain and suffering compensation is to be calculated. In the cases before the Court, the injured workers asked for an allocation of 30 – 35{b49237f8d5ca1472957084597003a717119f6f1cfb4eda5a47debe9535e6b419} of the total third party settlement. The Court warned that it would look negatively on any attempt to allocate a disproportionate amount of a third party settlement to pain and suffering since that could prejudice the workers’ comp insurer. Since all third party settlements must be approved by a DIA Judge at the Department of Industrial Accidents or a Trial Judge at the District Court or Superior Court, all parties including the workers comp insurer will have an opportunity to be heard at a third party lump sum settlement hearing. Now that the playing field has been balanced, injured workers and workers’ comp insurers should be encouraged to compromise and agree on a fair distribution of third party settlements that will compensate the injured worker and reimburse the insurer for its lien.

If you were Injured, Now is the Time to Get the Justice you Deserve

If you or a loved one was injured on the job, this case is great news for your claim.  The playing field has evened out, so injured workers can get the compensation they deserve.  The faster you act, the more your attorney can’t protect your rights, so contact an experienced Massachusetts Workers Compensation Attorney today!

Photo via Wikimedia by Tomas Castelazo

Real Stories From
Our Clients

Attorney Sheehan has been serving the needs of Boston-area residents since 1993. Our mission is to ensure complete client satisfaction and to obtain the maximum possible settlement or verdict for our clients.

Historias Reales de Nuestros Clientes

El abogado Sheehan ha atendido las necesidades de los residentes del área de Boston desde el 1993. Nuestra misión es garantizar la satisfacción de nuestros clientes y obtener el mejor acuerdo posible en sus casos.

"John Sheehan is a highly knoweldgable and all around amazing lawyer!" Si volvemos a necesitar un abogado para algo en el futuro, USTED será a quien llamemos.

I was injured at work in 2019 and John and his team made the process as simple as anyone could!! They took care of everything! The only thing I had to do is rest and go to doctor appointments! I would HIGHLY recommend anyone looking for an attorney to hire John Sheehan - if you would like a nice and easy process in a highly stressful situation and on top of it attorney Sheehan will get you the maximum of what your case is worth!

John Sheehan y su personal son muy amables, corteses, rápidos y explican todo a fondo. Hicieron un trabajo maravilloso para mi esposo y para mí y no podría recomendar un abogado más calificado. Hizo TODO lo que pudo por mi esposo y por mí a través de la compensación de trabajadores. He recomendado y continuaré recomendando a John a cualquiera de mis amistades que necesiten sus destrezas. Trabajo asombroso. John, Muchas gracias tanto de Al como de mí. No puedo agradecerte lo suficiente por hacer todo lo posible por nosotros. Cada vez que teníamos una pregunta, devolvía nuestras llamadas rápidamente. Esperamos no haberte vuelto loco. Si alguna vez necesitamos un abogado para algo, USTED será a quien llamemos. Muchas gracias de nuevo. ¡Gran trabajo! John, me gustaría darte las gracias aunque Judy ya lo hizo. Usted es el major y el personal de su oficina responden llamadas en seguida. Definitivamente lo recomendaremos a nuestros amigos si necesitan sus servicios. ¡Gracias nuevamente por un trabajo bien hecho!

- Jon P. (Google) Judy y Al Crowe